This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience.
Remember when influencer marketing felt like a breath of fresh air? It was genuine, it was relatable, and it felt like your favorite online personality was genuinely sharing something they loved.
Fast forward to today, and you might hear whispers of declining trust, ad fatigue, and a general eye-roll when another "sponsored" post pops up. So, what happened? Is influencer marketing losing its magic? Not quite, but it's definitely evolving, and it's time to get real about why some ads just aren't hitting the mark anymore.
The truth is it’s complicated. It isn't just about influencers shilling products or brands over-advertising. It's a nuanced dance between creators, brands, and the ever-savvy audience.
Let's talk about what makes an influencer ad good. We recently chatted with our exclusive creator, Joeseppi, and he summed it up perfectly:
"Integrity is the golden word. As a creator, I would only ever work with brands that I personally recommend. Your viewers can just see right through you, and you can't fake these people. You need to speak from the heart!"
Authenticity and credibility are the bedrock of effective influencer marketing. It’s about more than just a quick buck; it’s about respecting the time and attention your audience dedicates to your content. Joeseppi, for instance, dedicates serious effort to make his ad reads as enjoyable and seamless as his regular content, ensuring the viewing experience remains top-tier.
So, what can we really take from this?
This is the secret sauce that made influencer marketing explode in the first place. Audiences formed genuine connections with their favorite online personalities, leading to a belief that the products and services they recommended were truly embraced and used by them. When that authentic belief is missing, it’s noticeable. Your audience isn't just watching; they're feeling the vibe, and they can sense when something isn't genuine.
A stellar ad read doesn't just stick to a script; it organically melts into the influencer's existing content or at least perfectly matches their unique style and vibe. If it feels forced, clunky, or like a boring read-through from a briefing document, people will skip it.
For creators, this means putting in the effort! It's not just about hitting your talking points; it's about crafting an integration that entertains and engages, just like your other content.
For brands, this translates to trust. Trust your booked influencers. Give them the creative freedom to transform your briefing into a holistic experience that resonates with their audience. When you empower creators, they can deliver something truly special that hooks their viewers, rather than just ticking boxes.
At Audiencly, we can't stress enough the importance of precise targeting and reaching the right communities. It's all about balance. While there's a place for marketing through repetition and building widespread awareness, there’s a fine line. Cross it, and you risk "overmarketing" and losing credibility. This is especially true when you start partnering with any creator who has a large following, without proper due diligence.
This "overmarketing" is a two-way street. Creators who do integrations for absolutely everything will inevitably lose credibility (circling back to point 1 – where's the heart in that?!).
Smart brands vet their influencers, and smart influencers vet their partnerships.
Is trust completely gone when it comes to product recommendations from content creators? Not really.
If you look purely at the numbers, content consumption is skyrocketing. YouTube is steadily becoming the new primetime, and more and more people are even getting their news from social media and content creators. The core trust and interest in influencers as sources of information and entertainment haven't changed.
What is changing is the widespread adoption and massive investment in influencer marketing. More brands, big and small, are booking influencers. With that influx comes a natural increase in advertising. And, just like with traditional TV ads back in the day, if these ads aren't entertaining or engaging, people get bored, annoyed, and quickly learn to skip them. The aversion grows.
This is the moment for brands to really lock in. Understand the communities you're stepping into through your booked influencers. Adjust your marketing approach accordingly.
A huge first step? Connect deeply with your creators, give them the creative freedom to transform your briefing into something truly captivating for their audience. That's how we bring back the magic of influencer marketing – making it feel less like a hard sell and more like the friendly face on the internet, showing you their new favorite thing.
